• noun: the policy of trying to ensure one’s own survival or that of
one’s social or national group.
I have noticed a very sad trend in the prepping community. It’s a lack
of critical thinking and rationality. It’s a problem of illusions and
fear. This is my attempt to help dispel some of that, or at least
channel it constructively. Most new preppers are told to create a
threat analysis as their first step. This is a fantastic idea, except
that a moment later they are usually then given really bad advice.
That advice is in terms of suggestions of things to worry about. I
have seen dozens of these lists, and almost always have a very serious
flaw. They list everything from home invasion, to local natural
disasters, to TEOTWAWKI events. They seem to uniformly fail to
actually have a rational threat analysis in them.
Statistics are your best friend and worst enemy. Statistics can be
scary. They can also be horribly misleading if you lack data. Everyone
is told that most car accidents happen close to home, but nobody
bothers to think about the fact that most car Trips happen close to
home. Seeing the statistics for the number of people who get mauled by
bears is interesting, but more helpful if you include the statistics
for the number of people who think it’s funny to poke them with
sticks. Yes there are 18 thousand homicides each year according to the
CDC. Very scary until you realize that that’s 0.006% of the
population, and that 630 thousand die from heart disease and 117
thousand from accidents. That doesn’t even take into account how much
of those deaths are gang/drug related, and the fact that most people
are killed by someone they know, and not a stranger. I’m not saying
you shouldn’t have a defense plan; just that the diet/exercise and
safe driving plans need to come first.
Plan for the things that are most likely to kill you first, plan for
the unlikely things that scare the shit out of you second.
Planning for survival does not just mean planning for some future
event that might change your daily routine and the face of the world
around you. Planning for survival means doing things that increase the
statistical likelihood that you and your loved ones will live long
lives.
Having a huge cache of food to survive natural disaster or TEOTWAWKI,
while eating fast food every other day is Not Planning For Survival.
If you have a large collection of guns, but don’t practice the 4 Laws
of Safety, , you’re still not a survivalist.
If you have a great bug-out-bag, but can’t carry it up a flight of
stairs without getting winded, you’re still not a survivalist.
If your car trunk is equipped with enough tools and supplies to get
you through any disaster, but you drive like a soccer-mom on her
cellphone, you’re still not a survivalist.
If you have the best plans for TEOTWAWKI ever, but can’t manage your
day-to-day life, you’re still not a survivalist.
If you can hunt, clean, and cook your own food, but spend most of your
paycheck on booze and cigs, you’re still not a survivalist.
If you can make your own candles, forge your own steel, and farm your
own food, but can’t be bothered to switch off the modern electric
light when you change the bulb, you’re still not a survivalist.
If you can cut your own trees and build your own house with them, but
can’t take tool safety seriously, you’re still not a survivalist.
If you have tons of tactical training and the best equipment in the
world, but don’t bother to pay attention to your surroundings on a
normal day, you’re still not a survivalist.
If you drive drunk, you are an anti-survivalist.
If you eat tons of junk food, you are an anti-survivalist.
If you smoke three packs a day, you are an anti-survivalist.
If you drown your problems with alcohol, you are an anti-survivalist.
If you can’t maintain relationships with others, you are an anti-survivalist.
If you can’t be bothered to exercise regularly, you are an anti-survivalist.
This list goes on and on.
TEOTWAWKI events happen, just ask a European Jew. However they are few
and far between. The likelihood of you being killed, or even living
through one is less likely than some asshat running a red light and
t-boning you. Getting struck by lightning is rare, but avoiding large
open spaces while carrying your fishing pole in a lightning storm is
easy to do. Being eaten by zombies is pretty scary, but more people
die from infected paper cuts than zombie bites.
Prepping isn’t about creating plans that you will put into effect when
X Y and Z events occur. It’s about organizing your life to maximize
survival. Your daily routines will affect your rate of survival more
than any emergency response plan. Prioritize you preparations, plans,
and routines based on the true risks, and the ease of responding to
threats. First create a plan to alievate the risks you are already
artificially creating for yourself. A personal example is I don't
drive at night on the roads most infested by the rats with hooves, or
if I have to, I drive slower and more carefully. Wearing the proper
safety gear for whatever activity you are doing can make you more of a
survivor than any pug-out plan. After you fix the day-to-day problems,
then you can create a matrix of potential future threats by their
likelihood, severity, and the ease/cost of response.
Critical thinking is the single most important survival tool you have.
Use it as often as you can.
-Michael N
We are three friends who started a blog. We write about survivalism, libertarianism, guns, politics and the world. We also tend to talk about whatever we feel like. One of us talks about preparedness, guns and precious metals a lot. Another conspirator talks about all sorts of complicated legal stuff because he is in law school. The third co conspirator is mostly silent but has evil intentions and designs. We like what we like, enjoy what we enjoy and don't take shit off of anybody.
Looking for New Customers?
Well TSLRF is looking for a few good advertisers, or maybe a lot of good advertisers. We aren't really sure yet and are just going to see where this goes. If you are interested in advertising here then please send an email to theotherryan@gmail.com. We offer very reasonable rates and are willing to work with advertisers to come up with the kind of package that suits their individual needs. Our primary goal is to build long term mutually beneficial relationships with high quality businesses. The proceeds of this venture are going to go entirely towards preps.
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
11 comments:
TOR, thank you! Michael you hit the nail on the head! Excellent, to the point article.
Brian, You are welcome.
Nice article, but it's probably not fair to criticize survivalists in the manner you did. You've redefined survivalism from preparation for catastrophic events to making realistic threat assessments in daily living. I don't think the two are necessarily related in the survivalist political/social movement.
Plain old common sense is a very important tool to have...!
Jason Couch, Hmmm. I will have to disagree with you on that one. The two are definitely related like having a spare block of cheese in the fridge is related to having a 6 month food supply. Making sure you have a winter coat in the car and that the tank stays full is preparedness just the same way as having a gun or storing food is.
I think the article points out pretty obvious points and takes a holistic look at what preparedness is and should be. If anything MORE TIME and ENERGY should be spent worrying about and preparing for likely events than for the mutant zombie biker apocalypse.
As a final thought did you criticize this post for worrying about realistic threats that could happen on a daily basis?
If you had to worry about what COULD happen, a person would be paralyzed with fear and not even leave their bed - literally everything and anything can and has killed a person in some way or form.
I get what you are saying, but kind of agree with Couch. I do appreciate the time you took to write it - there are some good points to ponder - thank you.
No, not at all, I agree with the premise that you are more likely to increase your longevity if you make a realistic threat assessment of what is most likely to kill you in your current behavior and change it. There's actually not much I disagree with in the article except the premise that the survivalism movement is about increasing longevity.
I think it's a movement stemming from the Cold War that is about preparing for catastrophic events. It's not a let's-be-as-healthy-as-we-can-be-to-live-as-long-as-possible movement. That's why I think that redefining survivalism and criticizing survivalists for not conforming to the new definition is somewhat unfair.
It's one thing to say that "this is what I think survivalism should be concerned with" versus saying "this is what survivalism is and why you are all going about it the wrong way."
I only intended it to be a minor point, so I hope it doesn't seem like I'm trying to make a big production out of it, I'm just trying to express the thought clearly.
youre no fun.... quit ruining my good time
josh-
I have to say you hit me on a couple of those, Ryan. Very insightful post and you hit it into the cheap seats.
The mind is a great survival tool.
Good post.
See Ya
Sorry I've not had a chance to get back here yet, just wanted to mention a few things:
12, 2009 3:59: I don't say be paralized with fear. The point I was trying to make is that you can never guarantee survival no matter your plan. Your best bet is to just pay attention and examine your routines to eliminate as many threats as possible to increase your chances.
Jason: Why bother to prepare for the cataclysm if your end goal isn't to survive? I'm not redefining survivalism, I'm taking it to the logical endpoint. And it's not just me who's doing it, I'm not the first to say any of this.
Grumpyunk:I know, but a number of them were indictments of my own behavior as well. Don't think that I live up to my own standards (yet) It's an on-going process always.
Post a Comment